How to Tell Real Amish Furniture From Amish-Style Furniture (2025 Guide)

Not all furniture labeled “Amish” is truly Amish-made. Consumers often assume that anything rustic, simple, or made of wood qualifies — but the truth is far more specific. Genuine Amish furniture follows centuries-old methods, uses superior materials, and is made in small family-run workshops that take pride in craftsmanship over speed.

Here’s how to tell if a piece is authentically Amish-made, and why it matters for quality, durability, and long-term value.

1. Look at the Joinery: Dovetail &

Mortise-and-Tenon

Joinery is the single clearest sign of real craftsmanship.

Dovetail Joints (Drawers & Boxes)

Authentic Amish furniture uses hand-cut or precision dovetail joints.This technique locks two pieces of wood together without relying solely on screws or brackets.

Signs of real dovetails:

• Tight, interlocking “teeth”

• Visible craftsmanship inside drawers

• Smooth drawer glide without wobble

• Soft-close slides that still use dovetail joinery rather than stapled boxes

• No staples, glue globs, or cheap metal runners

• 
  

Machine-made furniture almost never uses real dovetails because they’re time-consuming and require skill.

Mortise-and-Tenon (Tables, Chairs, Frames)

This ancient joint is used to connect legs, rails, and bases.

A true mortise-and-tenon joint:

• Fits like a puzzle piece

• Is stronger than screws

• Holds weight for decades

• Prevents wobbling or loosening over time

  
  

If a table or chair uses this method, it is almost certainly built by an experienced craftsman.

Amish builders are known for both of these techniques — it’s one of their signatures.

2. Inspect the Wood: Solid Hardwoods Only

Real Amish furniture is made from solid American hardwoods, not particle board, veneer, or MDF.

Common hardwoods used by Amish builders:

• Oak

• Quarter-sawn white oak

• Hard maple

• Brown maple (very popular and more affordable)

• Cherry

• Walnut

• Hickory

Durability of Hardwoods:

• Last 50+ years

• Resist sagging

• Accept stain beautifully

• Age with character rather than cracking or peeling

  
  

If the piece is labeled “wood solids and veneers,” “engineered wood,” or “composite core,” it is not Amish furniture.

3. Customization Options = Real Amish Craftsmanship

Amish builders don’t mass-produce.Every order is built one at a time.

That means true Amish furniture always offers customization, including:

Wood species

Often 6–8 options including oak, maple, cherry, walnut, hickory, and brown maple.

Stain color

Dozens of finish choices — not just three generic shades.

Hardware

Knobs, pulls, hinges, and soft-close drawer slides can be selected by the customer.

Dimensions

Width, height, depth, leaf extensions, drawer count — all customizable.

Edge profiles

Mission, bevel, roundover, ogee, thumbnail, etc.

Upholstery

Leather, fabric, performance materials, nailhead trim, and more.

If a store claims to sell Amish furniture but offers zero custom options, it is Amish-style, not Amish-made.

4. Lead Times Reveal the Builder’s Process

One of the most misunderstood indicators of authenticity is lead time.

Amish furniture is not “fast furniture.”It is built in small workshops, without mass-production machinery, and scheduled around:

• Builder availability

• Seasonal demand

• Specialty finishes

• Hand-sanding & multi-stage varnish curing

  
  

Lead Time Example: Poly Outdoor Furniture

Poly builders see extremely high demand in:

• Late spring

• Summer

During these seasons, lead times can increase because:

• Orders spike

• Outdoor sets take longer to assemble

• Builders produce in batches

This is normal — and a sign of a real Amish workshop.

Lead Time Example: Hardwood Indoor Furniture

Indoor furniture builders often run 8–20 weeks depending on:

• The complexity of the piece

• Wood species availability

• Finish requirements

• Time of year

Longer lead times = higher authenticity, not lower service quality.

5. Amish-Style Furniture: What’s the Difference?

Many companies sell “Amish-style” products.

These are typically:

• Mass-produced

• Imported from overseas

• Made with veneers

• Built using metal brackets instead of joinery

• Offered in limited finishes

• Shipped quickly

If it looks Amish but ships in a week, it is not Amish-made.

6. Why Authentic Amish Furniture Is Worth It

Real Amish furniture stands out because it is:

• Built to last generations

• Crafted with pride and tradition

• Made from real hardwood

• Fully customizable

• Finished by hand

• Structurally superior

• Environmentally responsible

• It is the opposite of disposable furniture.

When you invest in an Amish-built piece, you’re investing in:

• Craftsmanship

• Ethics

• Durability

• Beauty

• American artisans

⭐ At Simon-Pure Amish Furniture, Authenticity Matters

Every piece we carry:

• Comes directly from Amish builders

• Is built-to-order

• Uses real hardwood

• Features dovetail joinery and mortise-and-tenon construction

• Offers soft-close drawer slides as an upgrade option

• Can be fully customized in wood, stain, hardware, and dimensions

  
  

Our showroom in Parker, Colorado displays genuine Amish craftsmanship — not factory-made copies.

If you’re unsure whether a piece is truly Amish, we’re always happy to help customers evaluate what to look for.

18870 Plaza Drive, Parker, Colorado

720-230-2900

simonpureamish.com